Bondi. If you want to
hear the recorded sound of a real band,
playing real instruments in a real space,
check out one of the albums he's worked on.
Considering how busy he his, I am grateful
to him for taking the time to do this
interview.
1) You are one of the few
producers/engineers who is also a
recording artist and songwriter... which one
came first and how did you get started? How
do you balance the two?
A lot of musicians I know have
made forays into engineering and producing
-someone I know recently joked about it being
an "inevitable Darwin cycle" from musician to
producer. It makes a lot of sense to me that
as an artist you would wantto have an
understanding and in that way some
control over how your music translates into a
recording, over the means of production. For
me it came very naturally out of being an
attentive, rapt listener and music fan,
wondering what it was about certain textures
and sounds or approaches to the "space" in a
song or piece of music that pushed the right
buttons for me emotionally as a listener,
always finding myself asking the classic
question "how did they do that?"
Unfortunately I don't really make as much
time as maybe I should to work on my own
music - as a freelancer, I tend to take as
much paid work as I possibly can and because
of the nature of making records, that tends
to be pretty all-consuming. Just keeping some
balance in this life can be like a full-time
job, as I am sure most engineers will attest to.
2) What albums were you listening to as
a kid that inspired you to
make your own music? What artists, past or
present, would you want to
work with now and why (You've already worked
with some of my favs, Vic
Bondi, Jeff Pezzati, Blake Schwarzenbach)...?
As a very little kid, I loved Black Sabbath
and the Beatles, but as I got into my teens,
I got really into movie soundtracks by
Bernard Herrmann and Jerry Goldsmith (some of
which, like Goldsmith's original Planet of
the Apes score, hold up well as pieces of
music unto themselves), and most of all
modern "Serious/classical" music - Samuel
Barber, Aaron Copland, Stravinsky, Bartok. I
loved how music in films could really pull
your emotional strings, usually without you
even knowing it. That was what really made me
want to make music. I didn't really get into
rock until I started hanging out with punk
rock kids in my high school art class -
regular rock and pop were way too codified
and totally bound up with what seemed like
prefabricated teenage social roles for me.
But I loved the punk rockers because they
showed some imagination and the rules were
being made up as they went along. So you had
a chance of following your own idea of what
was good or interesting and having someone
else take it seriously on its own merits -
which was very empowering and a lot more
compelling than just playing piano in my
parents' front room for hours, which is what
I had done up til that point.
The most
inspiring records I heard at that point are
still some of my favorite records: XTC from
Drums and Wires through English Settlement;
John Cale's Honi Soit and his "greatest hits"
comp Guts, Bauhaus, Joy Division, The Clash
London Calling, Husker Du Zen Arcade.
I think it could be amazing to work with John
Cale - I've read that a lot of the music he
made in the 80's - some of my favorite songs
ever - came together really spontaneously and
though I think it could have been a nightmare
in one way to work in that (apparently very
drug-fuelled) atmosphere, it's always
incredible to see something good and
interesting develop where there was literally
nothing minutes before - that to me is a real
gift. Joe Strummer is another one. I mean, it
could be a VERY long list - what inspiring
artist wouldn't you dream of working with?
More recently, I always wanted to record
Skeleton Key - I still want to. But I'm lucky
because it's easy for me to find something
inspiring in almost anyone I've worked with.
3) How would you describe your production
style? What do you emphasize?
I tend to work more with bands
rather than solo artists, which is not
necessarily out of preference but it's just
the way things have worked out. Though I do
like the way a band's group dynamic as people
comes through musically and I hope that's
something that translates to the recording.
Also, for better or worse I am obsessed with
drum sounds and performances. I think I
usually prefer to hear dynamics and dramatic
effect come out of performance, as opposed to
from some aspect of "production," if that
makes sense. But I like to try to heighten
whatever the inherent drama is within a song
by whatever means work best in a given
context. I want the song to be like a little
world, but that world is more interesting to
me if it's founded on the human interaction
of the players. Even if, method-wise, we're
talking about constructing an illusion of
performance rather than capturing everyone
playing live, I still like it to feel like a
real-time moment more than something static
and necessarily "perfect."
4) What are you presently working on? Any
plans for future Channels
releases or touring?
I am recording the NY band Rahim
right now, who I absolutely love. Paint it
Black are coming to the studio in August.
Report Suspicious Activity, which is a band I
play bass in with the songwriter Vic Bondi
(he used to be in the first wave Chicago HC
band Articles of Faith), Darren Zentek (also
drummer of Channels), and Erik Denno
(Darren's former bandmate in Kerosene 454 and
Oswego), has just finished our second album.
Channels will definitely record again and I
hope we'll play live but it's hard to get
that back into gear - it takes a lot of
rehearsal to get to the point where we can
feel like we're worth anyone's attention on a
stage. It's OK with us if things go slowly -
but we will do more as a band for sure.
5) I read your "Loudness Rant" on your
site re: the competitive drive
to make records louder (I completely agree,
btw) but I also think that
some of the responsibility is shared with the
mastering engineer and
not just the label or artist. I was
wondering, how much input do you
have or exercise when you or the band send a
record to the mastering
engineer? Do you get final approval as a
producer or do you have to
contend with the labels?
The final
say is almost always between myself and the
band. I've almost never had an issue with a
label about this ... but the rant came mostly
out of frustration because I have been
second-guessing this issue forever, thinking
"what is wrong with my mixes? I should make
mixes that hold up to this approach," in
other words, thinking I should be right in
there playing the competitive volume game, as
if that's job #1. But of course job #1 is
really using your imagination to serve the
music in the best way you can, and it's
cartoonish and ridiculous to me that that
somehow just boils down to making it the
loudest thing on shuffle play. I finally
concluded that I just don't like the 2007
"always-in-the-red" mastering aesthetic. It
just doesn't flatter my mixes and it seems to
me that the more I try to make mixes that
work with that mastering approach, the more
sort of generic and plastic-sounding they
are. It's fine if you don't care about having
a sense of space in the recording, or if you
use triggers for all the drum sounds - if you
want everything all crammed up in your face
all the time. But the very idea that there's
some absolute orthodoxy to this, and
especially that it centers around something
as juvenile as "make my record louder than
his record" is just anathema to me. As a
listener, a different-sounding or even
weird-sounding record beats a "perfect" or
"industrial-strength" record, always. It's
fine to have a loud record, and I would never
specify to a mastering engineer "make it
quiet," but come on, how loud does loud have
to be? That's why there's a volume knob on
your stereo. When you have to work very fast,
do a whole record in 5 days or something,
sometimes you end up trying to address mix
issues at mastering, and I used to fall back
on that a lot a long time ago. But avoiding
that approach is really important to me now.
6) I think your former band Jawbox was one
of the seminal bands from
the late eighties and early nineties... how
did the move from Dischord
to the major label Atlantic positively or
negatively affect the band?
Was there a difference or was it just a
logical evolution?
There is a
MASSIVE difference between Dischord and any
major label. Dischord just isn't a part of
the mainstream music industry at all, and
that is a very special and wonderful thing
that we were lucky to be a part of. But the
move gave us a new lease on life in a way -
we really needed a new context in order to
continue. It wasn't about money or exposure
necessarily, as much as just a change of
venue and seeing what else we could do. The
move definitely gave us the opportunity to
make our best music and afforded us some
great experiences. However we ended up in a
bit of a weird middle ground by trying to
move to a major but still do business our own
way. With benefit of 20-20 hindsight, we
should have either been totally careerist
about it and consciously aimed for total rock
stardom (because that's all the mainstream
music biz really understands), or not have
made the move at all. But it was stil a lot
of fun and overall my only regret is that we
agonized so much about it at the time.
7) Where is the music business headed (or
do you care)? Have things
gotten better or worse for artists with the
advent of MP3s, iTunes,
Myspace, Game Soundtracks, etc. Does this
stuff affect you
differently as a producer than as an artist?
There's no way to generalize except that the
extremes seem greater: it's getting better
and worse at the same time. It's so much
easier to get music out to people but so much
harder for them to take it seriously, to take
it personally, because of the glut of
information. But it seems like there are more
potential income streams from music than ever
before, if you are prepared for your art to
be used in that way (in video game
soundtracks for example). Anyway I hope that
things are becoming more artist-centric. In
the death-throes of the major music industry
though we are going to have to cope with
things like watermarked promo CDs that report
back to HQ when they are illegally copied,
which is so Orwelllian and a total drag.
8) To veer from music for one second...
I've always admired your
subtle (and sometimes not so subtle)
implementation of socially
conscious/political lyrics, what's a current
event you've been
contemplating? What role does or should art
play in social
commentary?
I just think it's valuable & necessary to get
things off your chest, and it's also great to
hear a song or experience any kind of art
with a point of view that makes you realize
you're not alone in an insane world. The arts
are one of the last acceptable venues for
asking "unacceptable" questions, which I
think is a social necessity, but it's not
like that's a substitute for cogent political
thought and effort.
9) Let's follow that with a vapid and
trivial question (you gotta mix
it up): what's one piece of equipment you
absolutely can't live
without?
My API 3124.
10) What are you currently listening
to?
Lee Perry "Blackboard Jungle
Dub," Brian Eno "Another Green World," Liquid
Liquid, and this great French band called
Daria that Iain Burgess recorded at Black Box.
11) Last but certainly most important, how
is your son Callum doing?
He's
amazing. It's too big a subject to get into,
but he's great, right now he's in good health
and he's totally amazing to be around, he's
growing so much every day, it's mind-blowing.
Thank you for asking.